Why can years of teaching experience suddenly feel like they disappear when someone walks into your classroom to observe?
By Kim Lester
You've been teaching all morning.
Your students are engaged. You're moving through the lesson, asking questions, making adjustments, and responding to what's happening in front of you.
Nothing particularly unusual.
Then the classroom door opens.
Your administrator walks in, finds a seat, opens a laptop, and begins typing.
And suddenly, you're thinking about everything.
Was that the right question to ask?
Should I have given them more time to respond?
Am I moving too quickly?
Why did I choose to explain it that way?
And what exactly is being typed into that laptop?
Teachers, isn't it interesting how you can feel perfectly comfortable teaching a lesson until you become aware that someone is watching you teach it?
You haven't forgotten how to teach.
Your students haven't suddenly changed.
The lesson may be the same one you were confidently teaching five minutes earlier.
But something about the experience feels different.
And there's actually a reason for that.
It's called evaluation apprehension.
Evaluation apprehension refers to the concern we experience when we believe someone is evaluating our performance.
It's not necessarily about whether the person watching is critical or whether we expect a negative evaluation.
It's about becoming aware that what we're doing may be judged.
And that awareness can change the way we experience something we already know how to do.
Now, here's where this gets interesting for teachers.
Teaching requires you to make decisions constantly.
You decide when to move forward, when to slow down, when to explain something differently, when to ask another question, and when to let students work through a problem themselves.
Many of those decisions become increasingly natural with experience.
You know your students. You recognize their expressions. You notice when they're confused, even when nobody raises a hand.
You make an adjustment and keep going.
But when someone is observing, you may begin thinking about those decisions in a completely different way.
Instead of simply deciding what your students need, you may also begin wondering how that decision will look to the person watching.
And now you're doing two things.
You're teaching.
And you're watching yourself teach.
You're thinking about the lesson while also thinking about how the lesson is being perceived.
That additional self-monitoring can make familiar work feel less natural.
Consider something as simple as changing your lesson plan in the middle of instruction.
On an ordinary day, you might recognize that students need another example and provide one without giving it much thought.
But during an observation, you might hesitate.
Will changing the plan make it look like I wasn't prepared?
Will taking extra time affect my pacing?
Will the observer understand why I made that decision?
The instructional decision hasn't necessarily become more difficult.
But now you're considering how someone else might interpret it.
And that's an entirely different layer of attention.
There's another important piece to understand.
Psychologists have studied how the presence of other people can influence performance. This is often discussed through the concept of social facilitation.
Sometimes having someone watch us can improve our performance, particularly when the task is simple or extremely familiar.
Other times, being watched can make a complex task feel more difficult.
Teaching is not one simple, repetitive task.
It's a combination of instruction, decision-making, classroom management, relationships, timing, and responding to things you couldn't have predicted when you wrote the lesson plan.
So even if you've taught for twenty years, being observed can still affect how comfortable you feel.
Experience can strengthen your instructional judgment.
It doesn't necessarily eliminate your awareness of being evaluated.
And teachers, that distinction matters.
Because sometimes we judge ourselves for the feeling before we even have a chance to understand it.
You tell yourself, "I've been doing this too long to still get nervous."
Or, "I should be more confident by now."
Or maybe, "Why do I feel like a brand-new teacher every time someone walks into my classroom?"
But feeling uncomfortable while being observed doesn't automatically mean you lack confidence in your abilities.
It may simply mean you're aware that your work is being evaluated.
And there's something else worth talking about.
The person watching doesn't even have to be your administrator.
It could be a student teacher observing your classroom.
A parent visiting during an activity.
A group of educators coming through to see an instructional practice.
Or another teacher watching you demonstrate a strategy during professional learning.
The circumstances and stakes may be different, but the awareness of being watched can still influence how you feel.
Now think about what happens after the observation ends.
The person closes the laptop, thanks you, and leaves.
You continue teaching.
But your mind may not leave the observation behind quite so easily.
You remember a student who gave an unexpected answer.
You think about the transition that took longer than you planned.
You wonder why the observer started typing at a particular moment.
You replay a question you asked and decide you should have worded it differently.
And before long, you're evaluating the evaluation.
Except you don't actually know what the observer was thinking.
You know what happened in the classroom.
You know what you noticed.
But you may be filling in the meaning of those moments without having the information needed to do that accurately.
The observer could have been recording something positive.
They could have been noting a question for later.
They could have been documenting a routine or student response.
Typing alone doesn't tell you what someone thinks.
And this is where reflection and rumination can begin to look very similar.
Reflection helps you learn from an experience.
You consider what worked, what didn't, and what you might do differently.
Rumination keeps you replaying the experience without necessarily gaining new information or reaching a useful conclusion.
One can support your growth.
The other can keep you mentally sitting in an observation that has already ended.
Teachers, this is where we need to notice and name what's actually happening.
Notice when your attention shifts from teaching your students to monitoring how your teaching might look.
Notice when you begin questioning decisions you ordinarily make without hesitation.
Notice when an observation has ended but you're still replaying every small moment.
Then name what's happening.
Instead of saying, "I must not be as confident as I thought," try:
"I'm aware that my performance is being evaluated, and that's affecting how I feel."
Instead of saying, "I should be past this by now," recognize:
"Experience doesn't mean I stop noticing when someone is watching."
And instead of deciding that the observer's typing must mean something negative, remind yourself:
"I don't know what was written. I don't have to create an explanation without the information."
Notice what's happening.
Name it for what it is, not for what you think it says about you.
Teacher, that's where understanding begins.
And once you understand what's happening, you can make a more intentional choice about where your attention goes next.
You may not be able to eliminate the awareness that someone is watching.
You may not be able to make yourself feel completely comfortable.
But you can return to the purpose of the lesson.
What do my students need right now?
Do they need another example?
Do they need time to think?
Do I need to clarify the directions?
Is the adjustment I'm considering appropriate for the learning happening in front of me?
Those questions return your attention to the instructional decisions that actually matter.
And if you do receive feedback afterward, you can consider that feedback based on what was observed rather than what you imagined someone might have been thinking.
You can acknowledge an area for growth without turning one observation into a judgment about your entire teaching career.
Because one observation is one moment in a much larger body of work.
It can provide useful information.
It can identify something you want to strengthen.
It can also capture a lesson that didn't unfold quite the way you expected.
But it cannot tell the complete story of who you are as a teacher.
And this connects directly to what we're talking about this month with Keep the Focus the Focus.
Everything that pulls for your attention does not deserve equal access to it.
That includes the thoughts you have about how someone else might be interpreting your work.
Yes, observations matter.
Yes, feedback matters.
And yes, being reflective about your practice matters.
But while you're teaching, your students still need access to your instructional judgment.
They need you responding to what's actually happening in the classroom, not only to what you imagine the observer might want to see.
You can take the observation seriously without allowing the awareness of being watched to take over the lesson.
And when the observation is finished, you can learn from what actually happened without continuing to evaluate yourself long after the observer has left.
Teachers, being watched may change how you feel.
It doesn't erase what you know.
It doesn't cancel the experience you've gained.
And it doesn't mean the capable teacher who walked into that classroom suddenly disappeared when someone opened a laptop.
You're still that teacher.
Even when you feel a little different with someone watching.
Give yourself the same care you give everyone else.
- Kim 🩷🌿
If this resonated with you, there's a podcast created to support you and what you're experiencing at school. Teaching Without Losing Yourself -The Podcast explores the pressures teachers navigate and what it takes to notice, name, interrupt, protect, and return to yourself.
Watch or listen to our podcast on YouTube:
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLGeiImj1vEeEEcXhnOfPo6Zdj_3KDdzPC&si=Jh6bmguWZ7KC1pDP
The After the Bells Subscription Box Experience is currently sold out for new members as we focus on serving our current members.
When limited enrollment opens again, I want you to have first dibs.
Join The Looksie List for early access to our next enrollment opportunity.